NOLA Concert Grand Reference Gold Loudspeakers
Posted by Harry Pearson on Monday, December 2, 2013
I'll say it here and now -- these are the most fluidly musical
loudspeakers I have ever heard.
These new giant speakers from Carl Marchisotto, of Alon and now NOLA
fame, have made me question what I once thought possible. What it
does, it does without calling attention to itself. The sound is
seamless, the defining feature of what I consider a true reference
component.
Listening to "Pictures at an Exhibition" I finally heard the great
gate of Kiev. I saw it. The power of the orchestra comes through
without any hesitation. There is a real passion at play here. If you
have been searching for what I have (sonically speaking), then you owe
it to yourself to hear what these speakers can do.
I have put "Un Bal" through a thousand incarnations but have yet to
hear it as lifelike as we are hearing it now. These speakers give me a
reference from which I can adjudge the sonics of my system, my
recordings, and of course, all other components that may cross my
path. Somehow Carl has entered the golden years of his speaker design
and the Concert Grand's are his masterpiece.
On "Saturn" (Holst, The Planets XRCD) you hear everything. You hear
the bells, you hear the decay, the attack, and beneath it the bass,
but they are never blended together. The sounds, the individual
instruments, are never mixed up. I am hearing differentiations that I
have never heard before, and I know this track better than myself. How
did they get bass so clean and keep the highs so exquisite? All I can
really say that it is right, absolutely right. Carl's giant creations
are democratic in their representation of the sonic spectrum from the
top on down.
When I listen to these speakers I hear the music, and only the music,
and there is really nothing more to say than that.
~HP
Additional comments...
The NOLA Concert Grand Reference Gold loudspeakers give you everything
you could possibly want from a large "super" speaker. They are dynamic
as hell and have a massive soundstage. They push enough air on loud
passages to convince your insides that an actual orchestra of humans
set up shop in your listening room. But where the CGRG stands alone
is the ability to properly, and thoroughly, reproduce all variations
of music, including the smaller, the softer, and more delicate
moments.
They provide appropriate and accurate image size on solo voice and
smaller groups, a most difficult task for large loudspeakers. They
sound as fluidly natural on soft and delicate passages as they do on
the fireworks (and they will knock you flat on the loud, dynamic,
demanding stuff). Typically, mega-speakers are most suitable for
"large scale works", to be played at loud levels, because these
speakers always sound "large" (this is the trade-off). But this
tendency to produce "large" sounds occur even when the program is a
"smaller" source, stripping away the natural elements, taking you away
from the source.
According to Carl Marchisotto, the owner and designer at NOLA, the
CGRG was developed to "provided detail at realistic levels". Citing
that many speakers need to be played well above "live concert volumes"
in order to provide significant detail, Marchisotto "concentrated on
preserving the low level detail and also the jump factor. This
so-called "jump factor" is directly related to speed and therefore,
dynamic energy." In other words -- how fast the speaker can go from
ppp to fff. The effect of a large speaker capturing such intricate
dynamics can be startling, and with the CGRG, this ability contributes
to the overall "aliveness" we have been experiencing on our favorite
recordings.
The CGRG is quite the model of efficiency, with easy-to-drive
impedance (no 2-ohm loads here), so that even moderate power
amplifiers of 75-watts can easily drive them to concert levels (thus,
the ARC REF-75, which we have recently been using as our go-to
reference amplifier). Many speakers today are designed to be 4-ohms in
order to maximize solid-state amplification (and, quite possibly, to
make the specs look more impressive). The CGRG is 91dB at 8
ohms. Marchisotto decided that his statement speaker would need to be
easy to drive because he wanted to get "more music out of it."
The CGRG is an all-passive system with the 12 drivers per channel
controlled by the NOLA custom, five-way Unison five-board crossover
system. The drivers in the CGRG are all proprietary. The 12" subwoofer
drivers are low mass designs with extended response to 1000 Hz,
without the crossover (and they are only used below 40 Hz) -- which
is quite fast for a subwoofer driver. The CGRG do not incorporate 15"
or 18" subs, because, according to Marchisotto, "they are too slow to
blend with the rest of the design." There are four, 120mm (4 ½") bass
drivers, which have a slim seven grams of moving mass (compared to the
typical 30 grams or more for standard woofers). The Alnico magnet
system, along with the gold plated copper phase plugs, are in place to
help remove any and all dynamic coloration (which can be a common
problem with many woofer systems). There are four, 110mm open-baffle
dipole midranges with tri-laminate cones and a pulp bass. Marchisotto
chose these because he found they provide the "most natural midrange
sound". (These midrange drivers are also driven by Alnico magnet
systems.)
The midrange system operates as a short line source and the main
tweeter is a line source ribbon design. It is a true ribbon, 12 inches
long, with no extra diaphragm. This driver alone weighs 25 pounds and
utilizes a significant amount of neodymium magnets. The output of the
line source tweeter is supplemented at frequencies above 15 kHz by a
true ribbon super tweeter. According to Marchisotto, this driver
"helps improve the high frequency dispersion of the entire system."
So, how does it sound? Like music. Like the real thing. This speaker
captures bloom and transparency at the same time, a rarity for such a
large transducer. The individual notes bloom without washing over
delicate passages. The music just seems to flow through you. The
speakers compliment every style of music. They are at home reproducing
Carnegie Hall, Abbey Road Studios, RCA's Studio B, or Wally
Heiders. Electric music comes through with blazing power and
tone. Orchestras are massive with dynamics, presence, and deep
realism. Jazz quartets are intimate and natural. Every instrument,
every human for that matter, is in the right place. The music does not
need to be played at extremely loud levels in order to produce a large
soundstage (read: realistic) and this allows the speakers, however
massive in physical stature, to disappear. As HP says, "they are
there, but they are not there."
The Scaenas have been a large-speaker reference for some time now, and
they still are, but the NOLAs are a completely different animal. The
Scaenas were king when it came to three-dimensionality, but the NOLAs
are seamless in a way that I have yet to experience. They give the
music a living presence every single time.
I asked Marchisotto why he would want to build such an expensive
speaker. He explained, "the Concert Grand Reference Gold is a platform
where we can demonstrate our technology with the best possible
implementation. What we find here is that even with modest sources,
the results can be extraordinary. We therefore can separate
loudspeaker problems from system problems in evaluating the
performance of our lesser models. Without the availability of the CGRG
used as a reference, this would be much more difficult."
He continues, "a significant challenge was to see if we could equal
the musicality of our four tower Grand Reference VI Gold, in a
two-tower format. The CGRG will perform in a much larger variety of
spaces than the four-tower system, and this makes it more relevant in
terms of its performance. Another reason is the "trickle down"
concept. We learn techniques when developing the ultimate models that
can be applied to lesser models. There would not be a KO model with
its outstanding performance at its price, were it not for the
development of our ultimate models."
Given the price tag, it is perhaps more pertinent to say that these
are a "must hear" product over a "must have" one (although, if price
is no matter, these are most definitely a must have). Meaning: These
speakers will provide you with a musical reference that you will hold
for the rest of your life, giving you a benchmark of what is possible,
allowing your perceptions of what recorded sound sounds like to
shatter and rebuilt anew.
There are many speakers available in this elite class of six-figure
loudspeakers, the luxury end of audio, so there is no need to chastise
NOLA alone for offering a product so few can obtain (there are
countless audio components that are designed for the exclusive few,
including the rare one-off). The fact that NOLA uses the technology
and research developed for its flagship speakers to infiltrate their
less expensive, smaller designs (such as the Boxer and KO) is clearly
evident, in design and the sound. The Concert Grand's are the obvious
highlight in NOLA's two-tower system (there is a four-tower version
available with dedicated Subwoofer towers), but listen to any of the
recent NOLA speakers and you will hear the same defining feature --
they breathe music, effortlessly. Listening to these speakers have be
a revelation.
~JSW